Earth Built Almost Entirely from Inner Solar System Material
ETH Zurich researchers analysed multiple isotopic systems across meteorites, Martian samples, and asteroid Vesta and found that Earth accreted from a single inner-Solar-System reservoir — with less than 2% contribution from material beyond Jupiter's orbit, challenging the standard model that outer Solar System objects delivered a significant fraction of Earth's volatile elements including water.
- Jupiter acted as an effective barrier against outer-disc mixing rather than a conveyor of water-rich material inward
- Multi-element isotopic analysis spanned meteorites, Mars samples, and Vesta simultaneously — the broadest cross-check applied to this question
- If Earth's water was locally sourced, the habitable-zone formation model for exoplanets requires revision